The Pet Food recall sentence

2010-02-08T21:25:00Z

What's About To Happen With The Pet Food recall!

Below is the story about the sentencing for the owners of ChemNutra, I believe they got off too easy, while the American public got a slap in the face!

This is a story from the Pet Connection Blog:

Pet food recall: ChemNutra owners to be sentenced today

By Christie Keith

February 5, 2010

Today's the day that Sally and Stephen Miller, owners of ChemNutra, Inc., the company that imported the melamine-laden protein powder that led to the 2007 pet food recall, and the illness and death of tens of thousands of dogs and cats, will be sentenced.

But if you were hoping for justice or even just tough love, you're probably going to be disappointed.

    Sentencing is scheduled for Friday, February 5, 2010, at 10:00 a.m.
before United States Magistrate Judge John T. Maughmer. As more fully explained below, the Government recommends that the Court adopt the agreement of the parties and impose a sentence of three years probation on each defendant, to include certain conditions of probation for each defendant, all as set forth and agreed to by the parties in the plea agreement.

The government concludes the Millers were at fault, and what they did caused great harm:

    Because of the neglect of these defendants, because they failed to exercise foresight and vigilance, the public suffered greatly.
Thousands of innocent pets became seriously ill and many suffered death. It is impossible to talk about this case without realizing that the defendant's criminal conduct posed and caused substantial physical injuries, death, and psychological injuries.

Seems the Millers are still balking at the charges, even though they've plead guilty to them -- and the government's not very happy about that:

    The defendants plead guilty to misdemeanor violations of the Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (FDCA). Particularly in this case, the nature, circumstances, and seriousness of misbranding and adulteration crimes go far beyond the misdemeanor label that is attached to them.

And this:

    Every factual objection [they are making] can be traced to one or more allegations in the indictment which the defendants either admitted was true or agreed could be used to determine their sentence. By raising these objections, the defendants could be viewed as being in breach of the terms of the plea agreement.
In case of breach, the Government is released from its obligations under the agreement, the defendants remain bound by their guilty pleas, and the defendants are sentenced without the benefit of the promises made by the Government.

    [....]

    (T)he defendants have never admitted that they knowingly imported wheat gluten that was misbranded and adulterated with melamine.

    In fact, the Government does not contend and does not ask the Court to conclude that the defendants had actual knowledge that the imported wheat gluten was adulterated with melamine.

    But the fact that the defendants did not actually know that the imported wheat gluten was adulterated with melamine does not prevent the Court, or anyone else for that matter, from concluding that the defendants acted recklessly or with more than mere negligence.

There's a lot more, including an overview of just how and why the Millers should have been able to detect and prevent this tragedy.
It makes for some rough reading.

I don't know what the actual sentence will be, but I'm pretty sure it will be along the lines laid out in the memorandum: Probation, and a small fine. That's it.

And the Millers still have their friends, too. Plenty of them sent letters (here and here) to the court testifying to what good, righteous, honest, religious, upstanding citizens the Millers are.
Not a word about what happened to the people and pets affected by the adulteration of the alleged wheat gluten with melamine -- but lots of sad stories about how hard this has been on the Millers.

Who are, I'm sure you'll be glad to know, back in the food ingredient importing business already.

Please leave your comments, we would like to know how you feel about this.

About Us

2009-02-23T20:08:00Z

My wife, Diana and myself, Don Minor, care for feral cats and other animals: For those of you that love pets, we have a bunch of them. We take care of around 40 cats, 4 dogs, 1 sparrow that fell out of its nest, 5 raccoons that just love to eat the cat's food that is left out for the feral cats and whatever else finds its way here. We Are Looking for your help in saving these animals. it cost a lot of money not to mention time to care for them all. We are will to put the time in but the cost is growing and for this reason we may have to slow down on taking animals in but with your help and others like you we could afford to expand are program and make more room. Please see are dontions page at are website under: Save The Animals

My wife, "Diana" is working on a series of e-Books about feral cats and caring for them. I am sure she is going to have a lot of good information in them for you! They will be coming to the website soon! Be watching for them. The proceeds from these e-books will go to feed the kitties and what ever else finds it way here. Believe me when we say it take a lot of money to feed and care for these cats and other animals. We hope that you will support us by buying our products and e-books. Your friends, Diana and Don Minor Here at Do You Care About Your Pet.com.

Are very first E-book is out and its FREE

Download it now click on the blue link

I Want A Pet

Welcome

2008-10-22T19:57:02Z

Welcome to our blog.

We Like to know what you think on certain matter regarding your pets. Please post your comments and suggestions.

BLOG.DOYOUCAREABOUTYOURPET.COM

The Pet Food recall sentence

About Us

Our Other Website's

Please Visit Our Other Website

Welcome